If you are an Indian on an H-1B visa in the US, your next extension could face more questions than your last one. The US government wants to scrap a rule that tells officers to generally trust their earlier approval when the same employer files to extend the same job.
The proposal is not final yet, and the public can comment on it until 13 November 2026. Here is what the change means, who it affects and what you can do now.
What is the “deference” rule?
When an employer wants to keep a foreign worker for longer, it files Form I-129 with US Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) to extend the petition. Today, a regulation at 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5) tells USCIS officers to give “deference” to an earlier approval when the new filing involves the same parties and the same underlying facts.
In simple words: if USCIS approved your H-1B for a job last time, and nothing important has changed, the officer should generally accept that earlier decision. The officer can depart from it only if there was a material error, a material change, or new material information that hurts eligibility.
On 14 October 2026, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) published a proposed rule titled “Removing Deference to Prior USCIS Determinations of Eligibility” in the Federal Register. It would delete that regulation entirely.
What would change if the rule becomes final?
DHS says officers would still be allowed to look at a prior approval where it is relevant. What goes away is the requirement to start from a position of trusting it. Every extension would be judged on its own evidence, and the employer would have to prove continued eligibility again.
- Who is covered: all petitions filed on Form I-129, which includes H-1B, L-1, O-1, TN, E and P workers. H-1B is by far the biggest group.
- What it means in practice: more Requests for Evidence (RFEs), where USCIS asks for extra documents before deciding.
- What does not change: the eligibility rules themselves. DHS says removing deference “does not substantively change eligibility” for the visa.
- Timing: the current rule stays in force until a final rule is published and takes effect.
Why does DHS want this change?
DHS argues that the deference rule quietly shifts the burden of proof from the employer to the USCIS officer, because the officer has to justify any departure from the earlier approval. It also says officers may have prioritised consistency and speed over a full review of each case.
According to an IANS report on the notice, DHS cited site-visit data showing combined non-compliance and fraud at about 22% of H-1B extension sites visited in fiscal 2022–2025, when deference applied, against about 17% in fiscal 2018–2020, when it did not.
This is also not the first time the policy has flipped. The table below shows its history, as set out in the DHS notice.
| Year | What happened |
|---|---|
| April 2004 | USCIS memo tells officers to defer to prior approvals for extensions with the same parties and facts |
| October 2017 | USCIS rescinds the 2004 memo, saying it wrongly shifted the burden to the agency |
| April 2021 | USCIS brings deference back through its Policy Manual |
| December 2024 | DHS writes deference into regulation (8 CFR 214.1(c)(5)) |
| October 2026 | DHS proposes removing the regulation; comments open until 13 November 2026 |
How many people could be affected?
DHS estimates that about 208,000 petitions a year would be affected. That is its average for fiscal years 2022 to 2025, when roughly 30% of all Form I-129 petitions were the kind of extension that qualifies for deference. In fiscal 2025 alone, 235,583 of 714,810 I-129 petitions fell into this group.
Indians are likely to feel this the most. IANS, citing USCIS’s annual report to Congress, reported that about 71% of the roughly 399,000 H-1B petitions approved in fiscal 2024 were for India-born workers. Of about 258,000 approvals for continuing employment, the category that includes extensions, about 79% went to Indian-born workers.
Using its own data from the 2017–2021 period, when deference was switched off, DHS estimated that the RFE rate for affected petitions would rise by about 2.9%, after adjusting for wider trends. IANS put this at roughly 6,000 extra RFEs a year. DHS said it found no matching change in denial rates.
Delays are the bigger worry. IANS reported that the notice says petitions that received an RFE took 64 days longer to process on average over the last four fiscal years. DHS itself acknowledges that this can make planning harder for employers and add stress for workers.
What it means for you
If you are on an H-1B, L-1 or another I-129 visa, nothing changes today. But it is sensible to prepare for a tougher extension process.
- Ask your employer to file early. More RFEs mean longer waits, so do not leave the extension to the last few weeks.
- Keep your paperwork ready. Payslips, an up-to-date job description, client letters or project details, and proof that your role matches the approved petition can all help answer an RFE quickly.
- Tell your employer or lawyer about any job changes. A changed work location, title, pay or duties can affect eligibility, with or without deference.
- Answer RFEs on time. An RFE is not a rejection, but missing the deadline can lead to one.
- Know the pending-extension rule. According to the DHS notice, if an extension was filed on time and is still pending when your status expires, you may remain in an authorised period of stay and may be able to keep working while you wait.
If you have been laid off or are between jobs, also read our explainer on the proposal to end the H-1B 60-day grace period, and check the latest USCIS fees before your employer files.
How to comment before the deadline
Anyone can comment on the proposal. DHS will only consider comments filed through the federal portal at regulations.gov; emails and letters to officials do not count.
- Go to regulations.gov and search for docket number USCIS-2026-0529.
- Click “Comment” and write in English. DHS says the most useful comments point to a specific part of the rule and give data or reasons.
- Do not include personal details you do not want made public. All comments are posted online.
- Submit before midnight US Eastern time on 13 November 2026, which is 10:30 AM IST on 14 November.
The bottom line
The deference rule has changed four times since it began in 2004, and DHS now wants it gone for good. Removing it would not change who qualifies for an H-1B, but it would likely mean more document requests and longer waits for extensions, a burden that falls mostly on Indian workers. Until a final rule is published, the current rule still applies, so use the time to file early and keep your records in order.
This article is for information only and is not legal advice. Speak to your employer’s immigration attorney about your own case.





Leave a Reply